Identify key pieces of legislation from the Second new DealAssess the entire brand-new Deal, particularly in terms of its impact on women, african Americans, and Native Americans

Roosevelt winner his second term in a landslide, but that go not mean he was immune to criticism. His movie critics came indigenous both the left and also the right, with conservatives deeply concerned over his growth of government spending and also power, and also liberals angered the he had not done much more to aid those quiet struggling. Adding to Roosevelt’s challenges, the supreme Court struck under several crucial elements of the first New Deal, angering Roosevelt and spurring him to shot and ridge the court in his second term. Still, he gotten in his brand-new term with the unequivocal assistance of the voting public, and also he wasted no time beginning the 2nd phase that his financial plan. When the first New Deal focused largely ~ above stemming the prompt suffering of the American people, the Second new Deal placed in place legislation that readjusted America’s social safety and security net because that good.

You are watching: Which statement represents a view of an opponent of the social safety net?

CHALLENGES FROM movie critics ON every SIDES

While many civilization supported Roosevelt, particularly in the first couple of years the his presidency, the new Deal walk receive far-ranging criticism, both indigenous conservatives who felt the it to be a radical agenda to damage the country’s version of cost-free enterprise, and also from liberals who felt the it walk not administer enough help to those who needed it most.


Huey P. Long was a charismatic populist and governor that Louisiana indigenous 1928 come 1932. In 1932, he came to be a member of the U.S. Senate and also would have been a serious rival for Roosevelt in the 1936 presidential election if his life had actually not to be cut short by one assassin’s bullet.


The biggest threat come the president, however, came from corrupt however beloved Louisiana councilor Huey “Kingfish” Long. His not say of Roosevelt come in part from his own ambitions for higher office; Long stated that the president was no doing sufficient to aid people and proposed his own Share Our riches program. Under this plan, long recommended the liquidation the all large personal fortunes in order come fund direct payments to much less fortunate Americans. He foresaw giving $5,000 come every family, $2,500 to every worker, and also a series of yonsei pensions and education funds. In spite of his questionable math, which plenty of economists easily pointed the end rendered his regimen unworkable, through 1935, Long had a far-reaching following that over 4 million people. If he had actually not to be assassinated through the son-in-law that a regional political rival, he may well have been a contender against Roosevelt for the 1936 presidential nomination.

ANSWERING THE CHALLENGE

Roosevelt well-known that some of the objections of the brand-new Deal to be valid. Back he was still reeling native the supreme Court’s invalidation of vital statutes, he made decision to face his re-election bid in 1936 by unveiling an additional wave of legislation that he called the Second new Deal. In the very first week the June 1935, Roosevelt dubbed congressional leaders right into the White House and also gave lock a list of “must-pass” regulation that he wanted before they adjourned because that the summer. Vice versa, the plans of the an initial hundred work may have shored increase public confidence and stopped the most drastic the the problems, the 2nd hundred days adjusted the face of America because that the following sixty years.

The bank Act that 1935 to be the most far-ranging revision of bank laws because the production of the commonwealth Reserve device in 1914. Previously, regional reserve banks, particularly the new York to make reservation Bank—controlled by the powerful Morgan and also Rockefeller families—had dominated policy-making in ~ the commonwealth Reserve. Under the brand-new system, there would certainly be a seven-member plank of governors to oversee regional banks. They would certainly have control over to make reservation requirements, discount rates, board member selection, and also more. No surprisingly, this new board kept initial attention rates rather low, permitting the federal government to borrow billions of dollars of added cash to fund major relief and also recovery programs.


Painted through artists sponsor by the commonwealth One Project, this ar of Ohio, a mural situated in the Bellevue, Ohio post office, illustrates a busy commercial scene. Artists painted the communities where castle lived, thus creating visions that farms, factories, urban life, harvest celebrations, and more that still reflect the life and also work of the era. (credit: Works progress Administration)


In 1935, Congress also passed the Emergency Relief Appropriation Act, i m sorry authorized the single largest expenditure at the time in the country’s history: $4.8 billion. Practically one-third the those funds to be invested in a brand-new relief agency, the works Progress administration (WPA). Harry Hopkins, formerly head of the CWA, take it on the WPA and ran it until 1943. In the time, the program listed employment relief to end eight million Americans, or around 20 percent the the country’s workforce. The WPA funded the building of an ext than 2,500 hospitals, 5,900 schools, 570,000 miles of road, and more. The WPA likewise created the federal One Project, which employed approximately forty thousand artists in theater, art, music, and writing. They created state murals, guidebooks, concerts, and drama performances all roughly the country. Additionally, the job funded the collection of dental histories, including those of former slaves, which listed a beneficial addition come the nation’s expertise of servant life. Finally, the WPA also included the nationwide Youth administration (NYA), which provided work-study jobs to end 500,000 college students and four million high institution students.


Browse the Born in Slavery collection to examine an individual accounts of previous slaves, recorded in between 1936 and 1938, as component of the commonwealth Writers’ job of the WPA.

With the implementation the the Second brand-new Deal, Roosevelt likewise created the country’s present-day social security net. The Social defense Act established programs intended to help the most vulnerable: the elderly, the unemployed, the disabled, and the young. It contained a pension money for every retired people—except domestic workers and farmers, which because of this left numerous women and also African Americans beyond the limit of the benefits—over the age of sixty-five, to be paid through a payroll taxation on both employee and employer. Related to this act, Congress likewise passed a legislation on unemployment insurance, to be sponsor by a tax on employers, and programs for unwed mothers, as well as for those that were blind, deaf, or disabled. That is precious noting the some facets of these reforms to be pulled from Roosevelt detractors Coughlin and Townsend; the popularity of their movements offered the president an ext leverage to push forward this form of legislation.

To the advantage of commercial workers, Roosevelt signed into law the Wagner Act, additionally known as the national Labor relations Act. The protections previously afforded to workers under the NIRA to be inadvertently lost when the supreme Court struck down the original law because of larger regulatory concerns, leaving workers vulnerable. Roosevelt search to rescue this necessary piece of job legislation, law so with the Wagner Act. The act developed the national Labor relationships Board (NLRB) to once again protect American workers’ ideal to unionize and bargain collectively, and to administer a federal vehicle for labor grievances to be heard. Return roundly criticize by the Republican Party and factory owners, the Wagner Act endured several challenges and also eventually obtained constitutional ratify by the U.S. Can be fried Court in 1937. The regulation received the strong support of man L. Lewis and the conference of commercial Organizations who had long sought federal government protection of commercial unionism, from the time they split from the American Federation of job in 1935 over disputes on whether to organize employees along handmade or industrial lines. Complying with passage the the law, Lewis began a widespread publicity project urging industrial workers to sign up with “the president’s union.” The connection was mutually helpful to Roosevelt, who subsequently got the endorsement of Lewis’s unified Mine workers union in the 1936 presidential election, along with a sizeable $500,000 campaign contribution. The Wagner action permanently established government-secured workers’ rights and also protections from their employers, and also it marked the beginning of labor’s political assistance for the autonomous Party.

The miscellaneous programs that made up the Second brand-new Deal are noted in the table below.

Key program from the Second brand-new DealNew deal LegislationYears EnactedBrief Description
Fair Labor criter Act1938–todayEstablished minimum wage and also forty-hour workweek
Farm defense Administration1935–todayProvides negative farmers with education and economic support programs
Federal crop Insurance Corporation1938–todayInsures crops and livestock versus loss of revenue
National Labor relations Act1935–todayRecognized right of employees to unionize & jointly bargain
National Youth Administration1935–1939 (part of WPA)Part-time employment because that college and high college students
Rural Electrification Administration1935–todayProvides publicly utilities to rural areas
Social defense Act1935–todayAid come retirees, unemployed, disabled
Surplus commodities Program1936–todayProvides food come the poor (still exist in Food Stamps program)
Works progress Administration1935–1943Jobs regime (including artists and youth)
THE final PIECES

Roosevelt entered the 1936 presidential election on a wave of popularity, and he to win Republican opponent Alf Landon through a practically unanimous Electoral College poll of 523 come 8. Believing that to be his moment of strongest public support, Roosevelt chose to precise a measure of revenge versus the U.S. Can be fried Court for challenging his programs and also to pressure them against difficult his much more recent Second new Deal provisions. To this end, Roosevelt produced the informally named “Supreme Court packing Plan” and tried to fill the court in his favor by broadening the variety of justices and adding brand-new ones who sustained his views. His arrangement was to add one justice for every existing justice over the age of seventy who refused to step down. This would certainly have enabled him to add six more justices, expanding the bench from nine to fifteen. Opposition to be quick and also thorough indigenous both the supreme Court and also Congress, and also from his very own party. The succeeding retirement of Justice van Devanter from the court, and the sudden death of senator Joe T. Robinson, who championed Roosevelt’s plan before the Senate, all but signaled Roosevelt’s defeat. However, back he never received the assistance to make these changes, Roosevelt showed up to success in politics intimidating the current justices right into supporting his more recent programs, and also they upheld both the Wagner Act and the Social security Act. Never ever again during his presidency would certainly the supreme Court strike under any significant elements of his new Deal.

Roosevelt was not as successful in addressing the nation’s farming deficit. As soon as he gotten in the presidency in 1933, Roosevelt did so v traditionally hosted fiscal beliefs, consisting of the importance of a well balanced budget in order to keep public to trust in federal government operations. However, the major economic problems of the depression quickly encouraged the chairman of the prestige of federal government spending to create jobs and also relief because that the American people. Together he commented to a group in Pittsburgh in 1936, “To balance our spending plan in 1933 or 1934 or 1935 would have been a crime versus the American people. To do so . . . We need to have had actually to set our face versus human suffering with callous indifference. When Americans suffered, us refused to happen by ~ above the other side. Humankind came first.” However, after ~ his effective re-election, Roosevelt anticipated that the economic situation would recover enough by late 1936 the he could curtail security by 1937. This palliation in spending, he hoped, would curb the deficit. As the early on months that 1937 unfolded, Roosevelt’s really hopes seemed sustained by the many recent economic photo of the country. Production, wages, and profits had actually all went back to pre-1929 levels, while joblessness was in ~ its lowest price in the decade, under from 25 percent come 14 percent. Yet no sooner walk Roosevelt reduced spending once a recession hit. Two million americans were newly out of work as unemployment easily rose by 5 percent and industrial production decreased by a third. Breadlines began to develop again, while banks prepared come close.

Historians continue to controversy the reasons of this recession in ~ a depression. Some believe the fear of increased taxes forced manufacturing facility owners to curtail plan expansion; others blame the commonwealth Reserve for tightening the nation’s money supply. Roosevelt, however, blamed the downturn top top his decision to significantly curtail federal federal government spending in project relief programs such together the WPA. Number of of his closestly advisors, including Harry Hopkins, Henry Wallace, and also others, urged him to adopt the brand-new economic theory espoused by British financial John Maynard Keynes, who said that deficit spending was necessary in advanced capitalist economic climates in order to preserve employment and stimulate customer spending. Encouraged of the need of such an approach, Roosevelt asked congress in the spring of 1938 for extr emergency relief spending. Congress automatically authorized $33 billion because that PWA and WPA occupational projects. Although civilization War II would provide the last impetus because that lasting financial recovery, Roosevelt’s willingness to adapt in 1938 avoided another disaster.

Roosevelt signed the last considerable piece of new Deal legislation in the summer the 1938. The same Labor criter Act established a commonwealth minimum wage—at the time, forty cents per hour—a best workweek of forty hours (with an opportunity for four added hours of work-related at overtime wages), and also prohibited boy labor because that those under age sixteen. Roosevelt to be unaware the the war would soon overcome his legacy, yet this verified to be his last major piece of financial legislation in a presidency that readjusted the cloth of the country forever.

IN THE final ANALYSIS

The tradition of the brand-new Deal is in part seen in the substantial increase in nationwide power: The federal government accepted responsibility because that the nation’s economic stability and also prosperity. In retrospect, the majority of historians and also economists judge it to have actually been a significant success. The new Deal no only established minimum criter for wages, working conditions, and also overall welfare, the also allowed millions of american to organize onto your homes, farms, and also savings. The laid the groundwork because that an agenda of broadened federal federal government influence over the economic climate that ongoing through chairman Harry Truman’s “Fair Deal” in the 1950s and President lindon Johnson’s call for a “Great Society” in the 1960s. The brand-new Deal state that taken on its obligation for the citizens’ welfare and also proved ready to use its power and also resources to spread out the country prosperity it s long well right into the 1980s, and many the its tenets persist today. Countless would likewise agree the the postwar economic stability of the 1950s found its root in the stabilizing influences introduced by society security, the job stability that union contracts provided, and federal housing mortgage programs introduced in the brand-new Deal. The environment of the American West in particular, benefits from brand-new Deal tasks such as the floor Conservation program.

Still, Roosevelt’s programs additionally had your critics. Complying with the conservative climb initiated through presidential candidate Barry Goldwater in 1964, and also most often connected with the Ronald Reagan era the the 1980s, critics of the welfare state pointed come Roosevelt’s presidency as the begin of a slippery slope in the direction of entitlement and also the damage of the individualist spirit upon which the unified States had presumably occurred in the nineteenth and also early twentieth centuries. Back the growth of the GDP between 1934 and 1940 approached an mean of 7.5 percent—higher 보다 in any other peacetime duration in U.S. History, movie critics of the brand-new Deal suggest out that joblessness still hovered about 15 percent in 1940. If the brand-new Deal led to some eco-friendly improvements, it also inaugurated a number of massive infrastructural projects, such together the grand Coulee Dam top top the Columbia River, the came v grave ecological consequences. And also other shortcomings of the new Deal to be obvious and also deliberate in ~ the time.

See more: How Many Electrons Will Nitrogen Gain In Forming An Ion, What Does The Octet Rule Mean

African americans under the new Deal

Critics allude out that not all american benefited native the new Deal. Afri Americans in specific were left out, with overt distinguish in hiring practices within the federal job programs, such as the CCC, CWA, and WPA. The NRA was oftentimes criticized as the “Negro operation Around” or “Negroes ruined Again” program. Together well, the AAA left tenant farmers and also sharecroppers, numerous of whom were black, v no support. Also Social Security initially excluded residential workers, a primary source of employment for African American women. Dealing with such criticism beforehand in his administration, Roosevelt carried out some efforts to ensure a measure of equality in hiring methods for the relief agencies, and also opportunities began to current themselves through 1935. The WPA at some point employed 350,000 afri Americans annually, accountancy for virtually 15 percent the its workforce. By the close of the CCC in 1938, this program had employed end 300,000 afri Americans, boosting the black portion of that is workforce indigenous 3 percent in ~ the outset to virtually 11 percent in ~ its close. Likewise, in 1934, the PWA started to require that all federal government projects under the purview hire African Americans using a quota that reflected their percent of the local population being served. Additionally, amongst several essential WPA projects, the federal One Project had a literacy program that ultimately reached end one million afri American children, help them learn exactly how to read and also write.

On the worry of race relations themselves, Roosevelt has a blended legacy. In ~ his White House, Roosevelt had actually a variety of African American appointees, although most were in boy positions. Unofficially, Roosevelt relied ~ above advice indigenous the federal Council on negro Affairs, also known together his “Black Cabinet.” This group contained a young Harvard economist, Dr. Robert Weaver, that subsequently became the nation’s very first black room secretary in 1966, as President lindon Johnson’s Secretary the Housing and Urban Development. Aubrey Williams, the director of the NYA, hired much more black administrators than any kind of other commonwealth agency, and appointed them to oversee projects throughout the country. One vital figure in the NYA was mary McLeod Bethune, a prominent African American educator tapped by Roosevelt come act together the director of the NYA’s department of black Affairs. Bethune had been a spokesperson and an educator because that years; with this role, she ended up being one the the president’s foremost afri American advisors. Throughout his presidency, Roosevelt came to be the an initial to appoint a black federal judge, and the very first commander-in-chief to promote an african American to brigadier general. Many notably, he came to be the first president to publicly speak versus lynching as a “vile form of cumulative murder.”