You are watching: Up is down and black is white
Collects Punisher #19-24. Uber-gangster Nicky Cavella is back with a vengeance - this time hitting frank Castle wherein he the very least expects it - appropriate in the black color pit the his hardened heart. Through an unspeakable act, Nicky will certainly go ideal to the top of Frank"s "to-do" list - and there"s nowhere he"d rather be.Collects Punisher #19-24. ...more
The Punisher MAX (Collected Editions) #4, The Punisher MAX (Single Issues) #19-24, Marvel Saga: El Castigador #5 , much more
Finally, this is more in line with what I meant of ennis.. We see few of Frank's fragile side and him having to rely on rather which is nice for a change. The story is going back to being an ext personal with acquainted characters and the art is as an excellent as always, just now with the included depth the the story telling this ended up being a an excellent (albeit weird) read.Maybe this is going somewhere interesting. 4.0 the end of 5.0 stars Finally, this is more in line through what I meant of ennis.. We see several of Frank"s vulnerable side and him having to rely on others which is nice for a change. The story is going earlier to being more personal with familiar characters and also the arts is as good as always, just now with the added depth the the story informing this ended up being a an excellent (albeit weird) read.Maybe this is going what interesting. 4.0 the end of 5.0 stars ...more
flag 16 likes·Like·see evaluation
Feb 16, 2019 Tony rated it really liked it
Shelves: marvel_comics, punisher
Score: 4.33 the end of 5Grade: 87% (A) | AwesomeThis publication hits the soil running, yet now the tables have actually turned – frank is the target and also Nicky Cavella is the slightly disturbed man gunning because that him. Return the story includes some great characters and also a spectacular beginning, it i do not care a little disjointed towards the end and doesn’t quite stick the landing. However nonetheless, there is still tons of bloody good fun come be had actually with this one. Right here is my evaluation of The Punisher MAX Vol. 4: increase is down Score: 4.33 out of 5Grade: 87% (A) | AwesomeThis book hits the ground running, however now the tables have turned – candid is the target and Nicky Cavella is the contempt disturbed guy gunning for him. Although the story has some great characters and also a spectacular beginning, it i do not care a tiny disjointed in the direction of the end and also doesn’t rather stick the landing. However nonetheless, over there is still lots of bloody an excellent fun to be had with this one. Here is my evaluation of The Punisher MAX Vol. 4: increase is Down and Black is White:
The Good:We lastly get a solid sense of continuous in this collection with the return of a couple of interesting characters. Who else carry out I start with other than Nicky Cavella. This male upbringing absolutely wasn’t regular by any stretch of the imagination. Unpredictable, crazy and also willing come do everything it takes to acquire the task done, that is easily one that Ennis’ finest villains yet and also one of my favourites. And don’t also get me started on Auntie Mo (crazy old hag)! You start to sympathize with Cavella despite every one of his wild antics.
This publication had an excellent supporting personalities including O’Brien and Pittsy’s sister, Teresa. Both these women were not to be messed with unless you want a severe ass kickin’! Pittsy’s sister is basically a female version of Pittsy (from volume 1) and I believed it to be hilarious. She a tough and mean women, but every when in a while, she desires Nicky to slip her the beef. Together for O’Brien, at very first I wasn’t completely sold on her, but as the book progressed, ns became an ext and much more invested in seeing she come the end on top.
I also really appreciated the art in this one. As I continue reading on, the arts in this series keeps on getting better and better. Many notably, the panels v Frank space amazing! over there are details sequences of panels that capture his brute demeanor and it’s marvelous to stare at.
This publication happens come be fairly funny too. Rather than the one-liner jokes the we’re supplied to, it’s nice to watch these personalities (which Ennis has done a terrific job building) thrown right into awkward/humorous situations. To some degree, castle normal people like you or I, however it’s just hilarious come see just how they react to certain things.
The Bad:Although ns loved the personality of Nicky Cavella, his last tilt through the Punisher was fixed too easily which i felt cheated on. Ns think it was a case of me really liking the character, despite the character no really doing much – as well as stirring the pot, and also oh boy does he! I likewise loved the method his story ended. Word to the way – never ever make things an individual with candid Castle.
See more: Who Or What Is Most Likely An Antagonist In Robinson Crusoe? ?
Something the bothered me come a little degree was exactly how the story unfolded. The an initial chunk the the book is amazing! it lays under the groundwork for a important spectacular read. However, v such a solid beginning, the succeeding chapters of the story no able to maintain the high level of consistency. The pacing of the book felt slightly off at times especially when it began to juggle every the characters’ stories.
Conclusion:Overall, the story was good and the characters were awesome. Ns feel favor some characters were underutilized and also the story dwindled down towards the end, however I still had actually a an excellent time v this. Back I’m simply a few books deep top top Ennis’ run, ns haven’t felt any type of Punisher fatigue. This series has been a the majority of fun for this reason far and also I fan it come the personality development. If you’re trying to find a violent, vulgar and well-written comic, this series is definitely for you. Don’t believe me? simply look at how happy open minded is below! that’s him on a great day…
Nick Cavella is back. Among the most psychotic mobsters The Punisher ever confronted has went back for revenge, and also in the process he manages to worm his way into candid Castle's head far better than anyone's ever done before."Up Is under & black Is White", rather frankly, is a little of a mixed bag. On the one hand, this is wherein we start to see an ext of Ennis' Punisher world taking shape, as events and characters native a mix of various storylines (specifically both villains and supporting actors fro Nick Cavella is back. One of the many psychotic mobsters The Punisher ever faced has changed for revenge, and in the procedure he manages to worm his means into frank Castle"s head better than anyone"s ever done before."Up Is down & black color Is White", rather frankly, is a bit of a blended bag. On the one hand, this is wherein we begin to see an ext of Ennis" Punisher world taking shape, together events and characters from a mix of different storylines (specifically both villains and supporting cast from "In The Beginning" and also "Mother Russia") start to affect the overreaching story arc, and the means in which Frank interacts through and/or eliminates those personalities is incredibly entertaining. We additionally get an even clearer expertise of Frank"s drive and madness. Suffice it to say the man isn"t well. As Micro insinuated in "In The Beginning", Frank has likely always been this way, and the mix of his time in Vietnam and losing his family were all the was necessary to unleash the muderous beast that had been surprise inside of him.That gift said, the plot for this storyline tends to waver, and also often seems unsure of where it"s going. ~ a great set-up occasions seem to take place "just because", and the wrap-up, when satisfying on a visceral level, felt choose an overly quick method to finish what started as a fairly nuanced and complex story. But, as I said in my evaluation of "Kitchen Irish", even a "bad" Ennis Punisher story is still a good one. 3 1/2 stars (rounded to 4 for mmsanotherstage2019.com purposes). ...more
A mobster who thinks he deserve to take down the Punisher walk the unthinkable - digs increase Frank Castle's wife and also kids and urinates on lock while gift filmed. The clip is aired on TV and the rampage begins... Garth Ennis go a an excellent job of informing the story the this mobster and also his sleazy and also blood-soaked rise. I was interested throughout with the variety of psychotic individuals in this criminal underworld and liked the Ennis focuses on structure up character in the poor guys providing them an ext dimensio A mobster that thinks he have the right to take under the Punisher walk the unthinkable - digs increase Frank Castle"s wife and kids and also urinates on lock while gift filmed. The footage is aired ~ above TV and also the rampage begins... Garth Ennis does a good job of telling the story the this mobster and also his sleazy and blood-soaked rise. I was interested throughout with the number of psychotic people in this criminal underworld and also liked the Ennis concentrates on structure up character in the poor guys providing them an ext dimensions than merely being actors as "baddie" and also have Castle kill them. Castle"s bloody rampage is likewise well done, Leandro Fernandez does amazing job-related pencilling each panel beautifully. The just thing that I doubted was why would certainly a news channel attribute footage that dug-up skeletons and also a mobster urinating ~ above them? and why wouldn"t any type of police arrest the mobster for this? Anyway, it"s a gripping check out as castle kills his means to the wise guy and punishes him. Pure grisly action fun, it"s an additional brilliant publication in Ennis" Punisher series. ...more
Absolutely, brutally brilliant. What a comics! open minded is, through far, my favourite comic personality of all time. That is the most tragic one as well. Seek revenge he'll never have, trying to find his piece in punishment. He can't though, i beg your pardon is presented in #22. He tries come close his eyes however the just thing the sees is burnin', murderin' and also slayin', blood almost everywhere the world and his family members sayin' 'We room still dead, Frank'. 'That's what I obtain for resting my eyes' he says. Nothing summary The Punisher Absolutely, brutally brilliant. What a comics! candid is, through far, mine favourite comic personality of all time. He is the most tragic one as well. Seeking revenge he"ll never ever have, trying to uncover his item in punishment. The can"t though, i beg your pardon is displayed in #22. The tries come close his eyes yet the just thing that sees is burnin", murderin" and also slayin", blood everywhere the world and also his family sayin" "We room still dead, Frank". "That"s what I obtain for relaxing my eyes" he says. Nothing summary The Punisher better. Phenomenal series. Just re-read the after 10 or therefore years and also I"m simply amazed v everything: the plot, characters, drawing. One of the best Punisher"s the end there, folks! ...more
These simply get better and better. What kind of deal with the evil one did Ennis do in order to write so well??
flag 3 likes·Like·see testimonial
Sep 27, 2018 Steven rated it really chosen it
Shelves: comics, crime, marvel
In the BeginningKitchen IrishMother RussiaNicky Cavella is back in town and he's gained a plan. A method to gain at the Punisher. To make him hurt. To do him scream. And also when the drop's his guard, he'll die. Except Frank isn't play by Nicky's rules. He's gonna go on the warpath....So for me, this to be a return to type after the minor goofiness of mother Russia. It's Frank earlier in his organic element, except this time we have an old foe returning for part revenge. So allows go over some old stuff. Fern In the BeginningKitchen IrishMother RussiaNicky Cavella is back in town and also he"s acquired a plan. A way to acquire at the Punisher. To make him hurt. To do him scream. And when that drop"s his guard, he"ll die. Except Frank isn"t play by Nicky"s rules. He"s gonna walk on the warpath....So because that me, this to be a return to kind after the minor goofiness of mother Russia. It"s Frank earlier in his herbal element, except this time we have an old adversary returning for part revenge. So allows go over part old stuff. Fernandez is ago on board as artist and also like prior to his occupational is good. Great colouring, an excellent use that lighting and shadow with distinct looking characters all around. Several of the old characters return and they actually look better in this art style, specifically Roth and also Rawlins. The one part I"d say where the art drops down is the relenten of Cavella. In "In the Beginning" Cavella was attracted to look favor Andy Garcia roughly 40 years old. However here, he"s looks choose he"s in his twenties v slicked earlier hair and a spindly little body. The an initial time I review this arc, i was legitimately confused about who i was spring at.The plotline is quite decent with the mass of the arc being something the a character examine of both Frank and Cavella together we read on come an eventual showdown. We given moments from each of their resides that help define that they are, whereby they"re going and their major flaws and also probably downfalls. The layout of meaning is additionally distinct, with countless of Frank"s inner monologues express his deepest fears, flaws and even a dream succession which is actually quite terrifying to behold. At the same time Cavella"s backstory is meat out v flashback daydreams and also overall they"re told quite well and also equally together terrifying and also horrible to behold, return in a various way.Since the characters are the emphasis of the story this time, Ennis walk a good job of digging into the psyches of both Frank and Cavella and also we come away through some an extremely terrifying ideas. A lesser writer would look in ~ a character prefer Cavella and try to limpwrist a tragic backstory to him, shot and humanize that in a way to make him come across as sympathetic. However Ennis has small time for that shit. Cavella is a dreadful scumbag and also while one event in his youth was a dreadful thing to take place TO him, the remainder of his life demonstrates the he is nothing yet a degenerate cowardly monster.Frank meanwhile is given a most characterization around his violent streak and what specifies him and also it"s price quotes like this the make me shit mine pants:There’s a dream I have actually from time come time and in the dream, ns don"t stop. I death the soldiers and also the hitmen, the extortionists and also racketeers, the dark old fucks who send them the end to fight. I hold the trigger down until they’re all gone — yet I don’t stop. The innocents are watching, as with always; the slack-jawed thousands, gazing at the beast. My family lay red and also shredded in the grass. I challenge the crowd and bring the weapon to my shoulder. "If my people ends," ns tell them, "so does yours." The recoil starts and also I wake up. It’s simply a dream, I constantly tell myself. "It’s just a dream. It’s simply a dream.The rest of the characters are decently composed with few of the returning characters getting a lot much more screentime and also a lot an ext depth. Rawlins was just a CIA operative in mommy Russia, yet here we realize what an pure snake the is and what he"s capable of. It also helps that he"s been attracted a lot more distinctly this time around. Kathryn O"Brien also makes a return performance and also here we see her true colours. She"s a lot much more than a item of eye candy and gives some of the more introspective moment in the arc. She"s conscious of the shitty fucked-up life she lives, she"s conscious that that isn"t the way people live yet she stays it anyway. Increase is down, black is White indeed.Overall, increase is Down, black is White is a solid story, with good well fleshed-out characters and some truly nasty setpieces that execute a good job of characterizing and even humanizing some of the characters, also if its just in tiny ways.Up next, we have the darkest that the series, The Slavers. ...more
little time mob ceo Nicky Cavella wants payback versus Frank Castle. He sees an chance to desecrate the dig of his wife and also kids. Lock goes into a rage while still being the methodic crime killer that he is. Ennis create a topsy-turvy human being where increase is down and also black is white. Increase is under is a lot more violent than Barracuda with an ext screwed increase characters. Ennis writes violence into his story without defacing the story itself. Up is under is likewise a lot much more graphic climate Barracuda wi small time mob boss Nicky Cavella desires payback versus Frank Castle. That sees an possibility to desecrate the tomb of his wife and also kids. Lock goes into a fury while still gift the methodic crime killer the he is. Ennis create a topsy-turvy world where up is down and also black is white. Up is down is a lot an ext violent than Barracuda with much more screwed increase characters. Ennis writes violence right into his stories without defacing the story itself. Up is down is additionally a lot much more graphic then Barracuda with topics of incest and sexual assault. Punisher fans will certainly love this comic and also it is Frank lock at his best. I average worst. I carry out feel that Barracuda was a far better story and Ennis put a lot much more effort into character development, The only flaw in up is down is the it is one large bloodbath with a wise ass gangster who gained in means over his head. It was hard to provide a Punisher comic 3 stars but I couldn"t provide it any higher.Twitterdaplme2016 ...more
flag 1 like·Like·see testimonial
january 06, 2017 Luke Sims-Jenkins rated the it was remarkable
understand whats rarely in a Punisher comic? Not simply recurring characters, however recurring bad guys! Nicky Cavella native the an initial volume is earlier and he's dug increase Frank's family and also pissed on all the bones.What complies with is a dark rampage as the Punisher simply goes fricken mental. It's gruesome shit, friend kinda wanna root for Frank, however Ennis makes it hard and thats good writing.Some other personalities come back, Roth and O'Brien indigenous volume 1 and Rawlins from mommy Russia. Feels yes, really cool to have long kind s know whats rarely in a Punisher comic? Not simply recurring characters, yet recurring negative guys! Nicky Cavella from the an initial volume is back and he"s dug up Frank"s family and also pissed on all the bones.What adheres to is a dark rampage together the Punisher simply goes fricken mental. It"s gruesome shit, girlfriend kinda wanna root because that Frank, but Ennis makes it hard and thats an excellent writing.Some other personalities come back, Roth and also O"Brien indigenous volume 1 and Rawlins from mommy Russia. Feels yes, really cool to have actually long kind storytelling in a collection where thats really hard to traction off. Ennis additionally creates guys so vile, you want them dead and we discover a lot about Nicky Cavella. More than I"d ever before want to. I"d speak this is the ideal volume of Max Punisher yet, yet the publication gets better.Leandro Fernandez indigenous Kitchen ireland is earlier on arts duties! i love his Punisher and i favor his variation of few of the recurring characters better than mr LaRosa. Leandro just fits ideal in, every little thing is gritty and also dark, however not too dark. The arts is clear and crisp and i loved it. Recommended. ...more
even discounting the amazing work-related of tying together previous story-lines, this is more than likely one that the all-time good Punisher story just due to the fact that of just how artfully do the character occupational is. The Punisher doesn't have actually the deluxe of recurring characters all that often, therefore that absolutely is a crucial component that why this story works, but Ennis might have occupied it with new faces and also the arc would still have controlled to sing. The is dirty, disgusting, spits on taboos and exemplifies the nature of also discounting the amazing work-related of tying with each other previous story-lines, this is most likely one of the all-time good Punisher stories just due to the fact that of exactly how artfully do the character occupational is. The Punisher doesn"t have the high-end of recurring personalities all the often, so that definitely is a crucial component the why this story works, but Ennis can have populated it with new faces and the arc would certainly still have managed to sing. The is dirty, disgusting, spits top top taboos and exemplifies the nature of the genre in every the appropriate ways. ...more
Gangster Nicky Cavella choose a unique means to try and hold together the NYC mob under his dominion - through digging up the remains of open minded Castle's family and also using them to ignite a war against a typical foe. Cavella's unorthodox tactic gets outcomes - but not the ones that expects. Finally, someone figures out exactly how to placed the screws to Frank by utilizing his deceased family - wherein was this before? Gangster Nicky Cavella choose a unique method to try and hold together the NYC lot under his ascendancy - through digging up the stays of candid Castle"s family and also using them come ignite a war versus a usual foe. Cavella"s unorthodox tactic gets outcomes - but not the ones he expects. Finally, someone figures out how to placed the screws come Frank by making use of his deceased family members - where was this before? ...more
flag 1 like·Like·see evaluation
Oct 12, 2009 Stephen rated it it was amazing
certainly the darkest, bleakest and also most truly fucked up narrative arc in the collection thus far, but...I really liked it. Ennis go something different with this one. It delved a little an ext in the psychological depths the Frank.
The 4th volume in the Garth Ennis' standard Punisher Max run is another grand slam. Great story and characters linked with fantastic artwork. One of the ideal reinvention that a character due to the fact that Alan Moore's standard run ~ above Swamp Thing. The 4th volume in the Garth Ennis" standard Punisher Max run is an additional grand slam. Great story and also characters combined with an excellent artwork. Among the finest reinvention the a character due to the fact that Alan Moore"s classic run top top Swamp Thing. ...more
2-3 stars.Pissed turn off psycho pisses off various other psycho who subsequently really pisses off the currently pissed turn off psycho. The yes, really pissed off pissed turn off psycho climate goes on a cool but quick pissed turn off rampage until he can shot and specific his revenge top top the psycho. Impressive art and good writing. The best scenes were the ones there is no any activity and full of dialogue. Some an excellent scenes the slaughter. Some standard Ennis grotesques. The villain had a fleshed the end motive and also horrifying backstory that i apprecia 2-3 stars.Pissed off psycho pisses off various other psycho who subsequently really pisses turn off the currently pissed off psycho. The yes, really pissed off pissed off psycho climate goes top top a cool but short pissed turn off rampage till he can shot and exact his revenge top top the psycho. Exceptional art and good writing. The finest scenes were the ones there is no any action and complete of dialogue. Some good scenes of slaughter. Some standard Ennis grotesques. The villain had a fleshed the end motive and also horrifying backstory that ns appreciated. But the story... Meh, it to be ok. I can"t specifically pin under why i didn"t like the story much. Perhaps I just didn"t feel choose reading an action movie critical night. Every time ns try, ns tell myself, "well that is just a typical action genre trope so what"s my problem? girlfriend respect tropes and also cliches." The pacing was too rapid in order to facilitate jumping from gore to gore to gore. The most insightful bit was the ever beneficial enigmatic tried and also true lesson that revenge doesn"t pay. I expect I intended as much and signed up for it. I couldn"t put it down though so I intend that says something. ...more
Shelves: punisher, comic-collection, comics, thrillers, adventure, crime, action, thriller, criminal
Aiming to destabilize (heh!) Punisher and also send that on the rampage, mobsters desecrate the grave of Castle's family. This of food triggers the Punisher however in a method that mobster did not anticipate.Punisher is displayed pretty good here. Guy that feels favor is in a really bad dream yet still more than willing to continue with his vendetta against the arranged crime. Art is excellent and scenes of carnage left in wake of Punishers actions is truly stuff of nightmares.What placed me off a little bit is the method ch Aiming to destabilize (heh!) Punisher and send that on the rampage, mobsters desecrate the tomb of Castle"s family. This of course triggers the Punisher yet in a method that mobster did not anticipate.Punisher is displayed pretty great here. Male that feels choose is in a very bad dream but still more than willing to continue with his vendetta versus the organized crime. Arts is excellent and scenes the carnage left in wake of Punishers plot is truly stuff of nightmares.What placed me turn off a bit is the method characters speak - besides Castle they all curse and seem normally incapable of perfect a single sentence without uttering some curse or other. It simply seems exaggerated and also as together it kinda damages it for me (and ns am not stranger to cursing mind girlfriend :)). They simply seem unprofessional and kind that a .... Ridiculous.Recommended to fans of activity comics and also of food Punisher. ...more
The best part is once he walk to kill Cavella in the woods. It's practically poetic. The best part is once he go to death Cavella in the woods. It"s nearly poetic. ...more
A returning minor character comes up with a terrible plan to placed Frank top top tilt. Why this is a good idea is left to the reader to imagine. The Punisher becomes even much more unhinged 보다 usual.