Buffalo nickels were produced from 1913 to 1938. Nowadays, you have the right to determine Buffalo nickel value just by mintmark, the minting date, and its condition. Due to the fact that these coins are fairly rare, also a heavily worn coin is precious well above face value if it has a readable date.

You are watching: How much is a 1919 buffalo nickel worth


James Earle Fraser design the Buffalo (Indian Head) nickel. That obverse had actually a indigenous American rustic design, and the reverse was with an American Buffalo. The united state Mint featured the very first Buffalo nickel variety standing on dirt, v a ‘5 cents’ denomination placed on the top.

Unfortunately, together a style flaw led to the denomination come wear turn off prematurely, so the was readjusted in 1913. New coins obtained a denomination recessed below their rim.

The united state mint created 71 regular-issue Buffalo nickels at three places so that you can uncover three various mint marks:

Philadelphia without a mint markSan Francisco v S mint markDenver through D mint mark

Since Buffalo nickels don’t contain valuable metals, their value has been fairly stable over several years.

Determine Buffalo Nickel Value


Once you want to recognize Buffalo nickel value, you need to pass through three steps, including:

Determining date and mintmark – it is an important to find the mintmark and also identify the minting date before checking the worth chart.

Grading condition – The coin problem will significantly influence its value. You deserve to use images, examine YouTube videos, and also detailed descriptions to determine the almost right coin grade. However, just an skilled can offer you the real value.

Special qualities – many collectors appreciate varieties, so friend should examine your coin and try to recognize the many appreciated qualities. Keep in psychic that several of them can significantly increase the coin price.

Besides 71 regular-issue Buffalo nickels, the united state Mint created seven proofs and numerous varieties. Many of them tho exist, and they are hardly ever too expensive. Top top the other hand, coins in uncirculated ms 64 and MS 65 problems can it is in costly and are often rare.

Rare Buffalo Nickel Value


Rare Buffalo nickels, arrays (special or error coins somehow different from various other coins created the exact same year), or those with an essential dates (coins v a low mintage) are highly valuable. In many cases, collectors are all set to spend huge amounts of money to get hold the them.

Rare Buffalo nickel value from 1913 to 1938 by COIN HelpU

1914/1913 end date1916 dual die obverse1918 D 8/7 over date1935 dual die reverse1936 D 3 ½ legs1937 D 3 legs
Very good$283$6,420$1,624$67$1,175$528
Very fine$652$13,512$5,066$301$1,710$646
Extra fine$764$20,843$7,474$580$3,334$779
About uncirculated$1,494$30,331$17,393$1,667$4,504$1,214
MS 63$3,737$160,000$44,319$5,462/$5,246
MS 65$18,400/$224,250$25,300/$32,631

Be careful since you have the right to often discover these coins counterfeit or altered. Therefore, the is an essential to have it tested.

Proof Buffalo Nickels

Believe that or not, girlfriend can discover only seven proof Buffalo nickels. Evidence coins room those specially produced archival functions or checking matrices. They have actually sharp details through a distinctive brilliant surface.

Proof 63 Buffalo nickels value

Proof, variety I1913$1,350
Proof, range II1913$1,000

Keep in mind that the hatchet ‘proof’ doesn’t indicate the coin condition but the means of their production or manufacturing. Poof Buffalo nickels in an typical Proof 63 grade are highly collectible, so it is worth making an effort to find one.

See more: How Did Maya Die On Pretty Little Liars, How Did Maya St Germain Die


As you have the right to see, usual Buffalo nickel prices will selection only a couple of dollars. Top top the other hand, uncirculated coins with vital dates can grade hundreds of dollars. If you uncover one of those nickels, that is time come research and also check even if it is you are the lucky one.