The claim: thomas Jefferson said giving to those who space not ready to work-related endangers democracy

A Dec. 16 post to the Facebook page for conserve Southern heritage and background includes a a statement about democracy allegedly created by founding Father cutting board Jefferson. 

"The democracy will certainly cease come exist when you take away from those who room willing to work and give to those that would not," states the quote, i m sorry is credited to the nation"s 3rd president in a meme.

You are watching: A democracy will cease to exist

Save southerly Heritage and history is a society and social website that additionally posts conservative news and patriotic memes, follow to its facebook profile page.

USA TODAY got to out come the team for comment.

The statement has actually recent origins and also has no been discovered in Jefferson"s directory of writings.


More:Fact check: "Greatest hazard to American freedom" quote misattributed to cutting board Jefferson

Where is the statement from?

The quote can vaguely reference an excerpt that Jefferson"s 1816 translation of Antoine Destutt de Tracy"s "Treatise on political Economy."

De Tracy was a French philosopher and also economist, according to a story by the Mises Institute, a school of economics in Auburn, Alabama.


Jefferson"s full translation reads: "To take from one, due to the fact that it is thought that his very own industry and that the his fathers has acquired too much, in stimulate to preventive to others, who, or who fathers have actually not worked out equal industry and also skill, is to violate arbitrarily the first principle of association, — the guarantee to every one of a cost-free exercise that his industry, & the fruits got by it," according to the thomas Jefferson Encyclopedia.

The translate into is much much longer than the quote in the on facebook meme.

More:Fact check: cutting board Jefferson quote on totally free press, "words the a tyrant," is fake

What was misattributed come Jefferson is actually pulled indigenous a 1980s-era book.

"Dreams Come Due: Government and also Economics together If liberty Mattered" is a guide to libertarian ideology written in 1986, according to an editorial review from Publisher"s Weekly. The book"s author uses the pseudonym "John Galt," the hero of Ayn Rand"s 1957 novel, "Atlas Shrugged," according Rand"s website.

Rand is credited as a "frequent suggest of entry into the libertarian movement" by libertarian think tank The Cato Institute.

The statement around democracy referenced in the claim is lifted directly from page 312 the Galt"s book, according to a screenshot save on computer on Google Books.

There is no proof Jefferson composed or spoke the words credited to that in the on facebook post.

Our rating: False

We rate this insurance claim FALSE, based on our research. A facebook meme misattributes a quote native a 1986 book to establishing Father Thomas Jefferson. Over there is no record of Jefferson having written or spoken the words from the meme.

See more: What Is The Next Number In This Sequence? 41 29 35 23,17 Tiger Algebra Solver

Our fact-check sources:

Thank girlfriend for supporting our journalism. You can subscribe to our publish edition, ad-free application or electronic newspaper replica here.